The above picture is the perfect representation of the reaction me and
many others students have had when the word “textbook” comes out the teacher’s
mouth. Something about the word “textbook” just makes student’s skin crawl.
Unofficial studies show that students mentally check out of class once the
notion of reading multiple pages of a textbook is brought up. If I could I wish
I could give the mastermind behind chapter 6 of Subjects Matter a big hug. In
chapter 6 they touched on many things that I wished some of my grade school teachers
would’ve grasped. For some strange reason, if there is a textbook that is 275
pages long some teachers feel the need to go over those 275 pages plus the
glossary before end of the school year. The first thing chapter 6 touched on is
to avoid assigning the whole textbook. Most teachers will divide the number of
pages in the textbook by the number of days in the school year. How can a
student effectively learn that way? Students may actually read the assigned
pages, but how do you that they are actually learning? In today’s society where
students are faced with many statewide standardized tests, reading those 275
pages in a textbook means nothing if none of it is covered on the text. That
leads me to the next thing that chapter 6 covered which was to be selective
about what you are going to cover out of the textbook. Instead of reading a
whole textbook, teachers should just skim through the textbook and pick pages
out that actually apply to the standards. Chapter 6 covered many other helpful
strategies but, I figured once teachers apply those two things I discussed
teaching will be a breeze.
-WC: 292
Thanks Antjuan! I completely agree with your comments about the textbook. If it's true that many schools and teachers are dispensing with textbooks in favor of web-based learning, I wonder if there's a risk of a similar dynamic playing out with online texts. In other words, if teachers send students from web page to web page, how is that fundamentally different than a textbook? Maybe it is, but I can some risks to that approach if teachers assume too much.
ReplyDelete